Morning Sentinel
Don't use Australia as a model for gun control law
Kennebec Journal & Morning Sentinel Tuesday, May 22, 2007

As co-author of "Gun Laws and Sudden Death" (British Journal of Criminology, October 2006), I must clarify Australia's 1996 experience with gun bans and "buybacks" ("Gun control after Virginia Tech massacre? Not on your life," May 15).

Our peer-reviewed study found firearm suicides (about 80 percent of firearm-related deaths in Australia) fell more quickly after the bans and AU$500 million buyback than before. We concluded the gun laws may have influenced firearm suicides, but advised caution because suicides using other methods also fell from the late 1990s.

Suicide prevention programs and other social changes may have had overall effects. Drawing bold conclusions about gun laws and firearm suicide is thus premature. There was no evidence the laws affected firearm homicides -- a result consistent with at least two other independent papers on the topic.

Regarding mass shootings, Australia's close neighbor New Zealand has not had a mass shooting in more than 10 years, either. However, New Zealanders still use, for hunting and target shooting, the types of firearms Australia banned in 1996. Gun prohibitionists' promotion of Australia's dubious firearms legislation model is a reaction, not a solution, to the immensely complex issues underlying violence.

Dr. Samara McPhedran

Chairwoman

International Coalition for Women in Shooting and Hunting (WiSH)

Sydney, Australia


Reader comments

Sort by: Oldest first | Newest First

action jack of moscow, OH
May 22, 2007 11:13 AM
I work full time, attend classes, have a family and make an honest effort everyday to improve my life and live in a police society with others. I collect firearms for target practice, hunting, and self-defense legally, just like 98% of all other American gun owners. I take the protection of my family seriously, and take offense to "gunhaters" telling me how I better come up with a solution to inner-city gang violence, or lose the right of self-preservation. Yea.. "Go bother somebody else".report abuse
OldSmoker of Brunswick, ME
May 22, 2007 10:29 AM
Gunlovers have one answer to the problem of violent crime: "Go bother somebody else."
report abuse

You must be a registered user of MaineToday.com to post a comment. Register or log in.


MaineBusiness.com: Maine News Direct  Business Classifieds  Blogs
Arts & Entertainment: Calendar   Movies   Music   Dining
Travel: Maine Regions   Things to Do   Maine Guide   From Away   Vacation Rentals   Lodging Guide   Campgrounds
Outdoors: Biking   Fishing   Hiking   Hunting   Nature Watching   Outdoors with Children   Paddling
Other sections: myMaineToday   Seen   Blogs   Pets   Kids & Family
Classifieds: MaineJobs   Real Estate   Wheels   Marketplace   Celebrations   Place an ad
Portland Press Herald/Maine Sunday Telegram: News   Sports   Business   Editorials   Nemitz   iHerald   Obituaries   Special Reports   Reader Services
Subscriber Rewards Club  
Kennebec Journal: News   Sports   Obituaries   Opinion   Reader Services
Morning Sentinel: News   Sports   Obituaries   Opinion   Reader Services
Advertising: Advertising products   Audience   Content areas   Service   Contact us
Questions/Comments?
Copyright © 2010, MaineToday Media, Inc.