DEMONS AND DIFFICULTIES
Detroit veteran not getting promised post-war assistance
By ALAN CROWELL
Staff Writer
Kennebec Journal & Morning Sentinel 12/23/2007

DETROIT -- Last Christmas, Matthew Pennington was looking forward to life after the Army and even running a marathon on a prosthetic leg.

In June, when his prosthetic leg broke, Pennington, 24, was unable to get it fixed and lost a measure of his independence.

The months-long delay in getting his leg fixed was only the first of what he describes as a series of barriers that prevented him from getting the help he needed through the Department of Veterans Affairs.

Pursued by demons that followed him home from Iraq and frustrated by seemingly endless difficulties in accessing the help he needed, the Detroit man turned to alcohol and his life entered a downward spiral, almost ending in a drunken driving accident on Sept. 19.

Depressed and angered by his inability to get his life back on track, Pennington got drunk and drove into the wall of the Bank of America building on Exchange Street in Bangor, traveling at what a Bangor Police Officer later told him was about 55 miles per hour.

"It was my statement: 'I am done,'" Pennington said as he sat in his home next to a table piled high with medical paperwork.

But the crash that almost claimed his life signaled a breakthrough of sorts.

Hospitalized for days afterward, Pennington started receiving treatment for the post-traumatic stress disorder he was diagnosed with more than a year ago at the Walter Reed Army Medical Center in Washington, D.C.

Other help has come only after he and his wife, Marjorie, began speaking publicly about their problems. Pennington said he got fitted with new parts for his prosthetic leg on Thursday after he and Marjorie talked to the media this week about their problems.

After the prosthetic leg broke, Pennington said, he developed large bulbous infections on his stump that became so painful that he was eventually forced to use a wheelchair or crutches.

Now, Pennington said he has already seen a big improvement.

"It feels great. I am not limping any more, I am not using my cane," said Pennington, whose disability is classified as 100 percent service-connected.

Pennington spent three months and his 23rd birthday in Walter Reed after he lost his left leg and parts of his right leg and foot when an explosive device made of three 155-millimeter artillery rounds detonated next to his Humvee.

Pennington, a paratrooper, was the turret gunner on the lead scout vehicle that day -- April 29, 2006 -- when the bomb exploded about 12 miles north of Saddam Hussein's hometown of Tikrit.

A combat veteran who was on his second tour in Iraq and had already served one tour in Afghanistan, Pennington put a tourniquet on his shattered leg himself before other soldiers pulled him from the truck.

Back home in Maine, after more than a dozen operations at Walter Reed and learning to walk again, he thought he was ready to take on new goals, including college and a career in politics.

EARLIER OPTIMISM

In an interview given a year ago, he described himself as positive and looking forward to new challenges.

He said he wanted to be in a position to help other returning veterans.

This week, the still boyish Pennington at times shows flashes of anxiety and smokes cigarettes as he talks about the unexpected problems he encountered in the past year, a time he had expected to be moving forward, not falling further behind.

The Detroit man blames his long wait for medical care on the Veterans Affairs system, not the people who work for the federal department.

But more than 18 months after he was first wounded in Iraq, Pennington said he is still waiting for the benefits he needs to get an education and move on with his life.

"I would rather be depending on myself," said Pennington, who said he was discouraged by Veterans Affairs personnel from applying to Colby College in Waterville, where he hoped to study political science, because it was too expensive.

He said he also qualifies for about $8,000 worth of adaptive furniture to help him get around his home -- but he has only received a handle with suction cups to help him balance in the shower.

From the start, he said, the medical care he has received at Togus has not measured up to what he was promised, nor to the care his military friends receive in other states.

At his first visit to a physician's assistant at Togus, he said, he received two bottles of narcotic pain relievers.

When he complained that the pills left him listless and unable to function, he was told to take fewer of them.

He finally weaned himself off the pills entirely but the only thing he found to dull the pain was alcohol, he said.

Pennington said he had asked for, but never received, alternative pain management help.

"I would rather be back in the military in Iraq right now than dealing with the V.A. system in Maine," he said.

STRUGGLE FOR FAMILY

Marjorie Pennington, Matthew's wife, said it has been a struggle to get Matthew the help that he qualifies for.

"It has been a fight. A fight for my marriage. It is crazy -- they (Veterans Affairs officials) put a lot of stress on the family," she said.

Jim Doherty, staff assistant to the center director at the Veterans Affairs Medical Center at Togus, said Friday that federal law prohibits him from speaking specifically about Pennington's case, although he said he has been authorized to say that Veterans Affairs officials had been in contact with Pennington frequently before they received calls from the media.

In general, however, Doherty said Veterans Affairs works hard to meet Maine veterans' needs.

"I would consider it very rare that (veterans) fall through the cracks," he said.

Patients who need help with a prosthetic limb receive care in a timely manner, said Doherty, although he said the length of the wait may depend on what part is needed and on the sophistication of the unit.

When a stump becomes swollen, he said, it may also be necessary to wait for the swelling to go down before the patient can be refitted.

The Veterans Affairs medical center also has a pain management team that can treat discomfort with a variety of medications or other means, he said.

Mental health care is available at clinics at Togus, Bangor and Portland, and readjustment counseling for returning veterans is available at five Veterans Affairs centers located throughout the state, according to Doherty.

"We have all these services that are available but Veterans Affairs health care is voluntary," said Doherty.

OPTIONS

Care providers give veterans options and recommendations but Doherty said it is up to the veteran to choose the option that is right for him or her. They can also choose to do nothing.

Three full-time staff members work solely with soldiers returning from Iraq or Afghanistan, helping them get services and tracking their care, he said. Overall, he said, roughly 1,500 veterans of the conflicts in Iraq and Afghanistan receive medical care through the Veterans Affairs system in Maine.

Veterans Affairs workers try to meet with all returning veterans several times when they come home and also try to brief families before the veteran returns about benefits available, Doherty said.

A total of about 38,000 veterans receive health care through the Veterans Affairs system in Maine, he said.

Alan Crowell -- 474-9534, Ext. 342

acrowell@centralmaine.com

Bookmark and share this story: digg del.icio.us Reddit


Reader comments

Sort by: Oldest first | Newest First

1-10 of 10 comments:

C Walt of Hallowell, ME
Dec 24, 2007 12:54 AM
Vastly different? The KJ exposes the State with its head up its a** in both cases. In one- The State "redistributing" money from the working Mainers and business owners via taxes to support able-bodied dead beats. In the other- The State failing to intervene on behalf of a native son who lost a limb in combat, returned home inspired to work for the betterment of his state and country, and was then screwed, brushed aside or ignored. Something tells me that even though a good bulk of the blame deservedly belongs to the Feds, there are other States whose elected officials and veterans groups would insist that its own wounded combat veterans recieve whatever resources are needed. If the Federal Govt. falls short, we have a moral responsibility (particularly those of us who have never fought in a war)to make up the difference, whether that is money, medical care, or other services. As a taxpayer and voter, I would rather see more money going to care of/services for veterans, and less to able bodied welfare recipients.report abuse
Hermann Munster of AmishLand, PA
Dec 23, 2007 11:01 PM
C Walt - you are way off in your criticism of the family "juxtaposed" by the KJ. The two situations are vastly different.

But, hey, maybe you could use some of that negative energy you have to criticize for something positive. Since Togus can't seem to get its act together for the benefit of the soldier, perhaps you could help organize a building party for the benefit of the Penningtons. Are you up to that challenge? Help build the things Pennington needs for his house.

Suction cups for the shower? That's it? The VA ought to be ashamed of itself. Almost as ashamed as you should be of yourself for criticizing instead of lending a hand to the guy who gave his all for your freedom.

What say you, Mainers? Do you have a heart for this guy or will you just sit on your ample butts criticizing the less fortunate?report abuse
redfish of Largo, FL
Dec 23, 2007 2:55 PM
CLOSE ALL VA HOSP .A LOT OF GOOD PEOPLE WORK IN THEM HOW EVER IT IS AND HAS BEEN A FAILURE TO VETS.2ND RATE CARE.ITS THAT SIMPLE WASTED MONEY FOR 2ND CLAS 3RD WORLD CARE, DRUG EM UP IT WILL HELP MENTALITY.LET THEM GO TO A DOC OF CHOICE IN THERE TOWN AND THEN WHO EVER HE REFERS THEM TO.report abuse
C Walt of Hallowell, ME
Dec 23, 2007 2:53 PM
Kudos to the KJ for running this article in the wake of the story about the short-sleaved dead beats who want tax payers to pay for an increased handout for fuel. With apologies to the readers who felt the ultimate sympathy for the man who has been "unable to get a job offer" in the last 18 months and his wife who doesn't work or qualify for disability checks- the story about Mr. Pennington illuminates the shameful and perverse priorities the State has with respect to its budget. I would suggest an exchange- giving the dead beats' money (and then some) to Mr. Pennington, and offering our out-of-work/short-on-cash friends from the earlier article jobs in Iraq....but we would not want to endanger or dishonor the brave men and women in the Armed Services by expecting them to serve alongside such folks. Once again, thank you, KJ, for the juxtaposition of these articles this last week.report abuse
devildog of belgrade, ME
Dec 23, 2007 2:20 PM
SPC Pennington, one more thing. Stay away from the Narcotics or use the VERY sparingly. They also tried to get me to take them but I refused. The narcotics work and they are cheaper for VA to buy but the chance of addiction is not worth it. There are other meds that are non-addictive that they can get for you. Just remember that YOU are IN CHARGE of your care and have the right to say NO and don't be afraid to see a Patient Representative at TOGUS (they have always been very helpful and knowledgeable).
Also, remember that your education is free in a State College in Maine plus you also are to receive a monthly payment for books an other items.report abuse
devildog of belgrade, ME
Dec 23, 2007 2:07 PM
As a 100% DISABLED veteran I know VA benefits can be a trial. Even though I had 18 years of military service when I received a medical retirement it was still a maze trying to figure things out even with my years of experience dealing with the military and my wife did most of the work. I was originally in the VA system in Louisiana and it ran MUCH smoother than here.
The term "TIMELY" (as in the people who need help with a prosthetic are treated in a "TIMELY" manner) is different for a person needing a prosthetic and someone with all their limbs. Part of the problem is also the CUTS,and then more CUTS that have happened in the past years to the VA system. These SAME politicians making noise about the way our verterans are treated are the same one's that took the funding from them in the first place.
I am currently seeing a very good Doctor at TOGUS and have no complaints about my treatment, but it took time to get there. Don't give up SPC Pennington and hold your head high. It may take time but they'll get it straighened out eventually.
SEMPER FIreport abuse
Tam of Augusta, ME
Dec 23, 2007 9:04 AM
Mr Dougherty is just trying to sugar coat the VA, to make them look good. I used to work with the veterans to get them the hellp they deserve. I would go to any lengths. That is until I complained to management about other employees mistreating the veterans, or some using illegal substances while on the job. I was forced to either be fired or resign. I chose to resign. I was and am appalled at the treatment that new incoming vets get. Also some long time vets as well. I was often approached by vets to help them get the care needed. They knew I would do anything I could to help them. I found that if you had a caring heart and saw to it that the vets got what they deserved the VA didn't want you. If you complained to management about others mistreating our vets, they didn't get into trouble, I did. I still love the vets I met there and many actually cried when I left as did I. I really enjoyed working with the vets, they became my friends. I wish I could have continued my work there. I know alot of vets reading this know who I'am, please know that I think of all of you often. Togus needs to do what they are suppose to do for all vets. If they hired more full time doctors and didn't rely on docs and nurses from other states that only stay a short time {they get paid three times as much, plus housing to be at Togus} maybe our vets would get continuity of care. I hope to someday be able to help our vets again. I have a stepson who is a 1st Lt. in the Marines on his 4th tour in the sandbox. We hope that he will be home in Feb. Come on Dougherty and Sims quit the politics and overpaid management and cut down the totally useless jobs that have been created for nothing. The underlings end up doing those jobs anyway, and some of those in management just get a fancy title and outrageous pay for WHAT? Get rid of the union to, they do nothing for the employee, they do what managment wants and to heck with the employee. No union more money for vets. VA do your job help the vets!!report abuse
Dawn of Augusta, ME
Dec 23, 2007 6:56 AM
How does a young veteran "fall through the cracks" when they repeatedly get in front of you to ask for help? Doherty sounds more like a lying politician than an aid for beneficial services. I'd guess he was coached to promote Togus and other veterans services in a more positive manner than the reality. This kid did not fall through any cracks, he was shoved there like sweeping dust under a rug. Something our veterans services have been infamous for for decades. There's no excuse for treating these returning vets, who've lost so much, so deplorably. All they ask for is proper care and what they get is the pill of the day.
I know many people no longer support this war but you cannot deny these young men and women, returning home battered and broken, the support and care they deserve. Our government raises taxes in the name of doing just that yet the money always ends up going somewhere else. When these kids need something, it's not given without wallowing through mountains of paperwork and red tape. It's not a wonder so many lose hope.
Pennington sounds like a real go-getter. He, nor his family, deserve to be driven into the ground. Why doesn't our state employ someone exclusively to oversee the care of people like him? Budget shortfalls you say? This wouldn't be the case if Baldy trimmed some of the real fat in the budget instead of striking out at social and medical services every time he needed to save a few bucks. I don't see any staff reductions in the legislature or state house. I don't see any real measures being taken to move forward at all other than the typical cuts in schools, mental health, elder care. You never hear stories of poor state employees falling through the cracks.report abuse
sweetpea of winthrop, ME
Dec 23, 2007 6:47 AM
The help and care at Togus is not what Mr.Doughtery states it lacks alot of the needed help for our veterans. I know because I have seen it first hand and it is not up to what other states are giving the returning veterans. They need to spend more money they receive on the veterans and less higher than necessary pay to the people who run Togus and they need to have the doctorsa attend more updated seminars on a yearly basis. Some of the doctors and staff are still in the darkages. They are lacking in skills to listen to what the family members have to say as they live with the veteran and know first hand what is going on but NO they listen to the veteran who sometimes does not want to admit that he has a problem. I certainly hope that Mr.Pennington and his wife get the help that Mr.Pennington needs. As far as college goes he should not be discourage in getting a degree in what he is interested in. That degree is no more expensive than any other degree and he fought for our FREEDOM and desrves to get an education in what he is interested in. Give him and our other returning veterans a break and the care they need. The squeaky wheel gets ACTION.report abuse
Demothat of Augusta, ME
Dec 23, 2007 6:46 AM
Veterans Affairs seems to be a tad defensive this morning. I am glad to see folks bucking the government's follow through which for past generations of service people has been lacking. Today our system may or may notr be lacking. Has anyone given the returning service people a written estimate of the general length of time it takes to get certain things done, or possible complications that can slow progress. If people know about what to expect at certain junctures points in their recovery they may experience less frustration and irritability..report abuse

You must be a registered user of MaineToday.com to post a comment. Register or log in.