Rail trail fence will be 'ugly,' some say
By MECHELE COOPER
Staff Writer
Kennebec Journal & Morning Sentinel Friday, March 16, 2007

HALLOWELL -- Sticking a 51/2-foot-tall black vinyl, chain-link fence mounted on a concrete wall in the historic district doesn't set well with some.

The fence is part of the final phase of the rail trail on the south end of town along U.S. Route 201.

"When they finally build it, a lot of people will be saying 'What the hell is that,' " Councilor Tony Masciadri said Thursday. "It's going to have a big-city major-highway kind of look. It'll be ugly."

Masciadri said he had no idea the Maine Department of Transportation planned to build the wall out of concrete and chain link.

A wood and granite fence would have had less of an impact on the historic district, he said.

It also would complement the Chaudiere-Kennebec International Corridor turnaround across the street with its red brick walkway, granite curbstones and dark green railings, he said.

For the past two weeks, crews have been building a drainage system and retaining wall. Normal traffic resumed Thursday. Earlier in the week, traffic was restricted to a single lane between 9 a.m. and 3 p.m.

When Gerald Mahoney, president of Row House -- the city's historic preservation group -- found out about the 700-foot wall, he asked for an artist's conception or computer-generated illustration of what it would look like.

Walter "Andy" Hendrickson, who serves on the Friends of the Kennebec River Rail Trail board of directors, brought the illustration, supplied by DOT, to a community forum Row House held in January.

"I think it's fair to say everybody was surprised when they saw the image that was presented," Mahoney said. "It was believed what was going to be there would be unobtrusive and compatible with the historic district."

Peggy Duval, the state Department of Transportation's project manager, said plans for the fence in the final phase were presented at a public meeting in September 2005.

"We presented it at the meeting and met with all impacted property owners," Duval said Thursday. "Some property owners requested to speak with us individually, and we did. We discussed the wall and what we were going to be doing to enhance it."

She said the concrete wall system chosen resembles cut granite. The color -- a darker gray -- was ordered to look more like granite.

As for the black chain-link fence, she said that style has been used throughout the other two phases. She said the black vinyl tends to blend in better.

"The wall is needed because when it comes from the top of the hill to the road, there's quite a difference in height," Duval said. The wall maintains a grade that meets an American with Disabilities Act requirement, she said.

Initially, the trail was to be built up along the rail line, but the City Council voted to change the alignment so it would come down over the hill.

Masciadri said residents living above the rail line were opposed to the trail so close to their homes.

Meanwhile, Duval said the economic climate increased the final cost of the project from $2.4 million to $2.9 million.

Construction is expected to be completed the first part of September.

Mechele Cooper -- 623-3811, Ext. 408

mcooper@centralmaine.com


Reader comments

Sort by: Oldest first | Newest First

previous page | next page1-10 of 14 comments:

Harold Campbell of Largo, FL
Mar 16, 2007 7:06 PM
Lianna; Please do not lose any sleep about the youth painting the thing,they wont wait for permision. It will be painted as soon as no one is looking. report abuse
DrPepper of Largo, FL
Mar 16, 2007 6:58 PM
Having to have to live in Hallowell 2 years in my youth it is hard for me think that there is anything that could be an eye sore put in Hallowell. report abuse
Brian of West Gardiner, ME
Mar 16, 2007 2:14 PM
Not pickin a fight spanky...just stating the obvious!report abuse
Boats1 of Chelsea, ME
Mar 16, 2007 1:22 PM
To be or not to be a granite or a chain link fence... really does not matter...it is the end produce that is important.
Any good changes in Hallowell is an improvement.
Respectfully,
Boats1
report abuse
Bill Randall of Winthrop, ME
Mar 16, 2007 12:50 PM
We've had a long and lengthy democratic administrative process where everybody had an equal and fair opportunity to express their views. And now at the final stages of the project, we have a couple of people who didn't enjoin in the process expressing their dislikes of how the fence looks. I find this a little disgusting only because this kind of thing seems to happen time and time again.

Yes, Cruizer, I know you are a Bush loving war monger and if I said Merry Xmas or Hail Mary, you'd find some way to criticize me for saying that.

But that's great. You're doing exactly what I enjoy doing - expressing my views. Only I much prefer to keep my comments focused on the issue and not the person unless they happen to be a public or political servant whose wages I pay.
report abuse
spanky of Augusta, ME
Mar 16, 2007 12:29 PM
Brian,

Sounds like you are trying to pick a fight again. Don't you have anything better to do?report abuse
Cruizer of Augusta, ME
Mar 16, 2007 11:41 AM
Thanks Bill. Guess you couldn't resist taking a poke at someone exercising his/her freedom of speech. Isn't it great that we all have minds of our own? Have our own opinions? Our own levels of consciousness? Well, most of us anyway.report abuse
jdaugusta of Augusta, ME
Mar 16, 2007 11:12 AM
Mr. Randall I strongly doubt your sincerity on wanting peace and tranguility when very recently you took a very innocent story about a local fire and used it for a chance to get a very mean, unwarrented attack on local fire departments. Not once did I see any concern for the poor family that just lost their home. Maybe if you feel such a need for agreement in a community you could try to get along and help your neighbors and stop thinking you are superior to others in your community.report abuse
Fred Peters of Vacationland, ME
Mar 16, 2007 10:26 AM
When I walk the rail trail, I'm to busy looking not to step in dog poop to enjoy the view.report abuse
lianna wood of canaan, ME
Mar 16, 2007 10:20 AM
No one wants to look at an ugly grey concrete wall but instead of complaining why not set up a plan that will allow school students to paint a mural on it....that way it will be both practical and beautiful in a more special way then just simply using wood to make the fence......just a suggestion.report abuse

previous page | next page

You must be a registered user of MaineToday.com to post a comment. Register or log in.