Recently released killer wants name change
By DOUG HARLOW
Staff Writer
Kennebec Journal & Morning Sentinel Tuesday, March 13, 2007

By DOUG HARLOW

Staff Writer

SKOWHEGAN -- A former Hartland woman who spent more than five years in prison for killing her husband in 1999 has petitioned the county probate court to have her name changed.

Vella Gogan, 61, pleaded guilty to manslaughter in the shooting death and mutilation of Eugene Gogan in 1999 and was released from the Maine Correctional Center in Windham last summer.

She filed the necessary paperwork with the Somerset County Registry of Probate last month, according to documents.

Gogan's new name, if the petition is approved March 27 by Probate Judge John Alsop, will be Vella Ruth Pelletier.

"I want to go back to my maiden name," Gogan wrote in the application.

Contacted by telephone Monday morning, Gogan declined to be interviewed.

Gogan originally was charged with murder in the Oct. 1, 1999, death of her husband, who was shot three times in the head as he slept in the couple's home on Route 43, Athens Road.

The body of the 65-year-old man was cut into pieces and found six days later in the woods off Route 16 in Mayfield Township, north of Athens village and 25 miles from the couple's home.

Investigators recovered more than a dozen pieces of his body, including the torso and head.

Maine State Police detectives said the rest -- his hands, feet, parts of his legs and arms -- had been buried in shallow holes in the woods.

Vella Gogan said she had acted in self-defense against her husband of 37 years, who had been psychologically and physically abusive to her.

She said she feared her husband had planned to kill her. Two psychologists and two psychiatrists concluded she feared for her life and suffered from "battered-wife syndrome."

But the state prosecutor, Assistant Attorney General Andrew Benson, called Vella Gogan's actions a virtual execution and "the ultimate act of domestic violence."

Family members of Eugene Gogan agreed with Benson, saying the charge should have been murder.

In an angry and emotional statement to the court and to Gogan, Susan Estes, a niece, said she felt betrayed by the court system, which she said had gagged family members and treated Eugene Gogan's killer as the victim.

"There's been no justice for his death," she said at the time.

Vella Gogan pleaded guilty to manslaughter in 2001 because she feared a jury might not agree that she acted in self-defense and convict her of murder, which carries a 25-year minimum sentence in Maine.

Gogan was sentenced to 15 years in prison, with all but six years suspended, and six years of probation. A spokeswoman at the Department of Corrections said Gogan will be on probation until June 2012.

Cindy Dillon, clerk of the probate court in Skowhegan, said Gogan came in herself to file for the name change, a routine act by a widow or a woman who has been divorced.

"She does not have to come in for the hearing," Dillon said. "Adults changing their name don't have to come in unless a judge wants them to."

She said Alsop will review the petition March 27 and sign the order if it is approved and mail a certificate of name change to Gogan at her address on Middle Road, Skowhegan.

M. Michaela Murphy, a Waterville lawyer, along with lawyer Janet Mills of Skowhegan, represented Gogan in the manslaughter case.

Murphy said Monday she has not had contact with her former client. Mills said she has spoken with Gogan and said she thought it was time to leave the case to history.

"I think the case is long over with and people should put it behind them," Mills said. "She has paid her dues."

Doug Harlow -- 861-9244

dharlow@centralmaine.com


Reader comments

Sort by: Oldest first | Newest First

previous page | next page1-10 of 11 comments:

Leon Richard of Farmington, ME
Mar 13, 2007 4:19 PM
Amazing, truly amazing. I am stunned. Not surprised, but stunned. A little over five years in jail for killing someone and cutting them into little pieces? Only in Maine... and only a woman. Any man did that to his wife, he'd be old and dead, as well he should be, before he ever left the prison. Then again, maybe not... maybe not even old... they don't call it a "Criminal" Justice system for nothing. Nobody else can get any there....report abuse
TJ of Shenandoah Valley, VA
Mar 13, 2007 3:17 PM
Their one and only child together KNOWS the truth and she lived it for many years. She misses her Dad EVERYDAY!!! Despite what Vella GOGAN, her lawyers and the public says about him - Gene was a nice man and didn't deserve to die at the hands of his abuser. Men can be abused too! Most of them just chose to hide it because they're afraid to look like weak.

Quote from dvmen.org: In 100 domestic violence situations approximately 40 cases involve violence by women against men. An estimated 400,000 women per year are abused or treated violently in the United States by their spouse or intimate partner. This means that roughly 300,000 to 400,000 men are treated violently by their wife or girl friend.
report abuse
Greg Greg of Portland, ME
Mar 13, 2007 3:06 PM
Geez, Snuggles, it might be helpful if you are going to label someone who's opinion you don't like ignorant and not able to get things straight, to at least spell them correctly. Otherwise it makes you look just like the kind of person I was hoping to draw out into the open with my earlier remarks. Someone who believes the circumstances in their life are always someone else's fault. Like you.

Someone else posted to the effect they knew the parties involved here, and correctly characterized the actual victim in this case. Have a nice day. report abuse
Aaron White of Winthrop, ME
Mar 13, 2007 2:22 PM
Once again a shameful look at Maines Justice system. You kill someone period, and cut them up, you either A stay in prison for life, or B stay institutionalized for life, because that guy didn't get the presumption that she did. 6 years is a disgrace. report abuse
papasmurf of skowhegan, ME
Mar 13, 2007 12:18 PM
amazing how we will have a sex offender of 20 years ago regester for live,
but someone who kills we are told she paid her dues.....report abuse
Snuggles of Windsor, ME
Mar 13, 2007 11:58 AM
Have any of you been abused for 30+ years? I'm guessing not by the comments posted. Yes a man died. And yes he was killed by his wife. She was dead on the inside years ago. Her life was stolen from her years ago. Where do you get off passing judgement on someone when you have no idea (and I mean no idea) what she has gone through. Have you gone to bed at night wondering if the man/woman next to you with do something terrible to you in the middle of the night? And those of you who think the system is completely bias towards women don't have a clue. Trust me, women get the short end of the stick sometime too! OHH AND TO GREGGREG, SAYING "I'M AFRAID" DOES NOTHING! YOU CAN'T EVEN GET A RESTRAINING ORDER ON SOMEONE UNLESS THEY HAVE ALREADY CAUSE SERIOUS PHYSICAL HARM. If you're gonna post something at least have a clue. You clearly are speaking from igorance! This women isn't trying to look like a victim, the court system said she is a victim! Get it strait.report abuse
Greg Greg of Portland, ME
Mar 13, 2007 9:55 AM
I'm sorry for Eugene's family and Susan Estes for their loss and encourage them to file a civil wrongful death lawsuit. The reason this case is particularly egregious, not that females commit as much domestic violence as males, they do. Rather, the highjacking of law enforcement by victim feminists to prosecute family related assaults along their perverted gender stereotype. One benefit (lol) of this paradigm is that domestic violence laws, bad as they are, actually save men's lives. There is no need to resort to the cast iron frying pan or murder when simply saying the magic words (I'm afraid) will target any man as the presumed "real" abuser, virtually guarantee that person's eviction to the street, and ensure retention of the family's children, real estate, and finances. This happens daily and there is even a special window at every court house devoted to this purpose. Of course, faced with the conundrum of female domestic violence murderers, the victim feminists had to create a legal antithesis, called "battered woman syndrome" to excuse those few murderers who couldn't be bothered to apply for a restraining order despite the fact they're doled out practically without question, like tossing candy to children. I presume that at her trial, the question was asked, Why didn't you just apply for a restraining order? Silly question. Women suffering from "battered woman syndrome" also are inflicted with "learned helplessness" that prevents them from doing anything to help themselves because it may make "him" mad! These slick female lawyers have covered all the bases.

Five years goes by quick, and now this family will see this woman walking down the street, freshy expunged from sharing their name. I bet it won't be long before we see Pelletier in the news again, like Amy Dugas. After all, you can't take the domestic violence out of the girl. report abuse
TJ of Shenandoah Valley, VA
Mar 13, 2007 9:31 AM
Paid her dues - are you kidding me?!!! She's STILL trying to look like the victim! She was the abuser and you can ask any of their close family members or friends that witnessed it for years. She had two female lawyers that knew she could USE Violence Against Women to receive a lighter sentence. If this case would've gone to trial, the truth would've come out and there may have been justice for Gene. His side of the story was never heard. He wasn't allowed to crap in the woods without her permission and when they first got married in the 1960s he was ordered by her not to have contact with his young children and because he feared her, he didn't for 30 yrs. The next time they saw their father was in a cremation urn. When he started having heart problems in the 1990s and wanted to contact his children because he knew his time on earth was limited - she went off and that's why Gene is no longer with us. She had lost control over him and she couldn't handle it. DEAD MEN DON'T TELL TALES!
report abuse
Francoise Nadeau of Waterville, ME
Mar 13, 2007 8:05 AM
After being divorced 10 years I resumed my maiden name, by choice. It's my understanding that a person can change their name as long as it's not to defraud, and I don't think you need permission from the court to do so. It's understandable that this woman wouldn't want to carry her dead husbands name, after being battered by him, then spending 5 years in prison for and extra measure of punishment. Being stuck with his name just adds more insult to injury, plus the probation time she has left to do. At her age, it amounts to a life sentence of misery without recourse. If I were on a jury of her peers, I'd say get on another page and close the book. However, she's had no life, will have no future. Stuck in the same place, still doing time on probation, no place to go, and her whole life being difficult. Her plea for a name change doesn't warrant a mention in the KJ, but it should send a strong message to victims of domestic violence. If you're a battered woman, get out. Go away. Take a bus. Get a room. Get a job. Change your name. Get as far away as you can to start a new life, before you get killed, or you kill him. After-the-fact is "too late" and time is precious. It's all we have in life. report abuse
Blackacre of Winthrop, ME
Mar 13, 2007 7:23 AM
Reader, the reason the KJ wouldn't cover your application for a name change is because you didn't kill and dismember your husband. No bmatter how badly he treated her, he didn't deserve such a gruesome death. I think the story is newsworthy. Mrs. Grogan deserves to be reminded publicly of her heinous crime.report abuse

previous page | next page

You must be a registered user of MaineToday.com to post a comment. Register or log in.